Smart Money Talk Free newsletter

Are We in an AI Bubble? Lessons from History’s Biggest Crashes

Exploring the parallels between the AI boom and the dot-com bubble, the risks of financial mania, and the lessons history teaches us about technological revolutions.

When the man leading the biggest AI wave on the planet says he is worried people are about to lose a huge amount of money, it’s time to pay attention. Sam Altman, the founder of OpenAI, has openly expressed concern about the scale of financial losses coming from the AI boom. Just days ago, the IMF and the Bank of England issued warnings about a bubble similar to the dot-com era, highlighting the risk of a sharp, sudden correction in global markets.

Some say we are in a bubble. Others argue there is no danger, and that this is simply what a technological revolution looks like. So, who is right? To find an answer, we need to understand both sides of the argument and look at what history says about big tech shifts and the financial manias that often accompany them.


The Skeptic’s Case: Why the AI Boom Looks Like a Bubble

Since ChatGPT captured public attention in late 2022, the value of U.S. stock markets has surged by trillions of dollars, with much of this growth concentrated in a handful of AI-related giants. This rapid ascent has created a palpable sense of unease, reflected in the skyrocketing number of Google searches for “AI bubble.”

So, what is fueling this fear?

1. The Circular Money Flow

A primary concern is the appearance of “circular money washing.” Take the relationship between big tech and AI startups. Cloud giants like Microsoft, Google, and Amazon invest billions into companies like OpenAI and Anthropic. In turn, these AI startups spend a huge portion of that capital on cloud services and chips provided by the very giants who invested in them.

The money moves in a circle: it leaves as an investment and returns as revenue. This creates the appearance of booming sales, fooling investors and inflating stock prices until the bubble eventually bursts. This pattern is hauntingly similar to the accounting tricks that fueled the dot-com bubble.

Back then, the magic word was “internet.” Companies with no product, profits, or business model saw their stock prices skyrocket. The growth was driven by infrastructure spending on fiber-optic cables. But behind the scenes, much of this growth was an illusion. For instance, telecom companies would swap unused fiber capacity with each other, booking the deals as billion-dollar revenue without any real money changing hands. When reality caught up, the collapse was catastrophic.

Many observers believe the same pattern is happening today with AI, but on a much larger scale.

2. Aggressive Accounting and Tiny Revenues

Beyond circular financing, companies are using accounting maneuvers to flatter their numbers. For example, some firms are recording expensive, short-lived AI chips on their books as if they last for many years. This spreads the massive cost over time, making annual expenses look artificially low and profits artificially high. Other companies have started shifting their AI expenses into separate external entities, hiding the true cost from investors.

These financial games are happening against a backdrop of enormous spending and minimal returns. The AI infrastructure industry is expected to reach $300 billion in spending this year, yet total AI revenue in the U.S. is only around $12 billion. An MIT study found that 95% of companies adopting AI have not yet generated any financial return. Even with a tool as popular as ChatGPT, less than 2% of its users are paying subscribers.

This massive gap between spending today and revenue tomorrow is what many analysts point to as the clearest proof that we are in a bubble.


The Bull’s Case: Why This Time Might Be Different

To be fair, there is a compelling counterargument. Many confident investors believe this is not madness, but rather the price of building the future. They argue that the current situation is fundamentally different from the dot-com era.

1. The Players Are Stronger

In the late 1990s, the hype was driven by small, unprofitable startups with weak balance sheets. Today, the leaders of the AI boom are trillion-dollar empires like Microsoft, Google, and NVIDIA. These companies have massive cash reserves and are funding AI development from their profits, not from reckless borrowing. This makes the system far more stable.

2. The Fear of Missing Out Is Rational

For these tech giants, the true risk isn’t overspending—it’s falling behind. As Meta’s Mark Zuckerberg summarized, he would rather spend billions and be wrong than miss the biggest technological opportunity of our lifetime. This is a land grab for a new continent. Whoever arrives first gets the best land and controls the future platform. From this perspective, the spending isn’t irrational; it’s a strategic necessity.

3. Valuations Are High, but Not Dot-Com High

While valuations are certainly stretched, they are still below the levels of total insanity seen at the peak of the dot-com bubble. Bulls argue that if AI delivers on its promise of productivity gains, today’s prices will look reasonable in hindsight. They believe we are witnessing the construction of a new technological foundation, and big returns are just around the corner.


What History Says: Revolutions and Bubbles Go Hand in Hand

There is a third group—the realists—who look at history and see a recurring pattern. Every major technological revolution, from railroads and electricity to the radio and the internet, has been accompanied by a financial bubble.

The innovation is always real and world-changing. But the financial mania around it is also real. Capital floods in faster than profits can justify, a speculative bubble forms, and it eventually bursts, wiping out many investors. The underlying technology, however, survives and continues to reshape the economy.

This brings us to a more refined question. It’s not if the AI bubble will pop, but how. Bubbles don’t burst randomly; they are triggered by specific events. Here are three realistic scenarios that could do it.

1. Scenario One: The Domino Tower

The AI economy is a highly interconnected system. Cloud providers fund AI labs, which buy chips and services from those same providers. They all rely on each other’s success. If one major company stumbles—due to a product failure, a regulatory blow, or a revenue shortfall—it could trigger a domino effect. Confidence would evaporate, and the entire tower could collapse. We saw this in 2008: one bank fell, and the global financial system followed.

2. Scenario Two: A Major AI Safety Incident

AI is incredibly powerful, but the systems protecting it are still experimental. A single catastrophic event—a hacked model leaking sensitive data, AI-driven misinformation causing real-world chaos, or a rogue system escaping human control—could force governments to slam the emergency brakes. A global freeze on AI development would be imposed, and billions in investments would be stranded overnight. It’s a low-probability, high-impact scenario that could instantly burst the bubble.

3. Scenario Three: The Killer Invention

History shows this is often the most dangerous scenario. During the dot-com boom, a new technology suddenly multiplied the capacity of fiber optic cables, rendering billions of dollars of newly laid infrastructure obsolete. The same could happen in AI. A breakthrough in chip architecture, a leap in quantum computing, or a new algorithm that makes GPUs obsolete could destroy trillions of dollars in existing infrastructure. Every data center would become outdated, and valuations would collapse.


🧠 Smart Money Takeaway: The Revolution and the Bubble Are Both True

After weighing the arguments, we arrive at an unavoidable conclusion: technological revolutions and financial bubbles are inseparable. The AI revolution is real, and it will reshape our world. But the bubble is also real. The difference is that the technology and its major players tend to survive the crash, while the speculators do not.

The critical question is not when the bubble will burst, but who will be left standing when it does.

Your job as an investor isn’t to perfectly time the market. It is to position yourself to benefit from the long-term revolution without getting wiped out by the short-term bubble. This means focusing on companies with strong balance sheets and real cash flow, diversifying your investments, and being prepared for the volatility that inevitably comes when hype meets reality. The story of AI is just beginning, but for some investors, it could end abruptly. Make sure you are positioned to be on the right side of history.


Keep reading